From members’ clubs to historic pubs, our guide reveals the finest establishments where this national spirit takes centre stage.
It might be Fringe Festival season but it’s more than just performances attracting crowds to historic Edinburgh. The picturesque birthplace of Scotch whisky offers an unparalleled journey through the amber nectar that has defined Scottish culture, legacy and allure for centuries.
From atmospheric closes in the Old Town to modern establishments with castle views, the city’s whisky bars represent both tradition and innovation. Whether you’re a seasoned malt enthusiast or curious newcomer, these seven eclectic establishments, from the glamourous to the intimate, offer the finest drams and drinking experiences Scotland’s capital has to offer.
The Kaleidoscope Bar
Nestled at right in the centre of town at 28 Queen Street, The Kaleidoscope Bar serves as the welcoming face of The Scotch Malt Whisky Society, opening its doors to non-members six days a week. This sophisticated establishment specialises in single cask, single malt whiskies that showcase the extraordinary diversity possible when each barrel tells its own story. The knowledgeable staff excel at guiding visitors through their ever-changing selection, curating personalised tastings that reveal the subtle complexities of cask-strength spirits.
Beyond whisky, the bar offers expertly crafted cocktails and carefully selected wines, making it an ideal destination for both whisky purists and those seeking a broader drinking experience. Since it is also a members club, you’ll be rubbing shoulders with some serious enthusiasts, and feels like you’ve stumbled upon a secret right in the heart of the city.
SCOTCH at The Balmoral
Located within one of Edinburgh’s most prestigious hotels, the Balmoral, SCOTCH represents whisky appreciation at its most refined. The hand-crafted, oak-panelled cabinet houses over 500 unique Scottish varieties, spanning every major region from the peaty shores of Islay to the honeyed hills of Speyside.
Their passionate Whisky Ambassadors don’t merely serve drinks; they share stories, tasting notes, and their infectious love for “the water of life”. Whether seeking rare limited editions or discovering your first single malt, SCOTCH offers an education in Scottish whisky that matches the grandeur of its luxurious setting.
The Mother Superior
This vibrant Leith Walk establishment transforms whisky education into pure entertainment, located in the charming coastal district of Leith, now quite a mix of longtime locals and newer hipsters. With an impressive collection of 800 bottles, The Mother Superior has earned its reputation as a hip little temple to Scottish whisky knowledge.
Their monthly rotating selection of 20-40 specially priced drams makes exploration both accessible and exciting. The casual Louisiana soul food menu, crafted with premium Scottish ingredients, provides the perfect foundation for whisky appreciation. The intimate basement venue hosts regular jazz and funk sessions, creating an youthful atmosphere where music and malt harmonise beautifully.
Tipsy Midgie
This award-winning establishment proudly claims Edinburgh’s largest single malt selection, balancing prestigious rarities with approachable everyday drams. The owner’s culinary background shines through the innovative “Tipsy Treats” programme, where traditional chocolates meet exceptional whiskies in expertly crafted pairings.
Their popular Sunday Exploration Flights offer remarkable value at £10 for three distillery-focused drams, while regular Distillery Discovery Events bring Scotland’s whisky makers directly to patrons. The in-house Tipsy Tasters club provides dedicated enthusiasts with deeper exploration opportunities.
Johnnie Walker 1820 Rooftop Bar
Perched above the Old Town with commanding views of Edinburgh Castle, this rooftop retreat atop the Johnnie Walker Experience and Vault elevates whisky appreciation both literally and figuratively. The outdoor terrace becomes magical at sunset, when the castle’s ancient stones glow against Scotland’s dramatic skies.
While celebrating the Johnnie Walker legacy, the bar ventures way beyond its namesake brand into Diageo’s very large roster of whiskies. Apart from drams, cocktails are a highlight with a creative signature Black Ruby Tonic that combining Johnnie Walker Black Ruby with bitter tonic and sweet blueberry jam for a refreshing twist on tradition. It’s highly advised to book during high season and busy, sunny afternoons.
The Athletic Arms (Diggers)
Local character defines this traditional Edinburgh pub, affectionately known as “Diggers” for its unique location between two graveyards. Originally frequented by gravediggers who propped their spades against the bar after long days, it retains an authentic atmosphere that modern establishments struggle to replicate.
The impressive collection of over 450 whiskies comes with remarkably reasonable pricing, while six rotating cask ales maintain the pub’s commitment to traditional brewing. Match days near Murrayfield and Tynecastle transform this neighbourhood gem into a bustling celebration of sport and spirits.
The Devil’s Advocate
Hidden within an atmospheric Victorian pump house up Advocate’s Close, The Devil’s Advocate combines historical intrigue with contemporary sophistication. The 300-bottle whisky collection complements a seasonal Scottish menu that changes regularly, reflecting the kitchen’s commitment to local ingredients.
Dishes like whisky-cured Scottish salmon and specially selected steaks from master butcher John Gilmour showcase how local cuisine and whisky enhance each other. The award-winning bartenders craft inventive seasonal cocktails alongside their impressive whisky selection, while the unique décor and cosy atmosphere make this Old Town hideaway feel like Edinburgh’s best-kept secret.
